With so many brands on offer, it’s not easy to figure out the best one for you. Different systems have different features but all will allow you check the temperature at a glance and set schedules so you’re using your heat when you need it most and ensuring you don’t waste any when you’re out. Beyond that, there are more advanced features, including geo-location, which can automatically turn off your heat when the last person leaves, and open window detection to make sure you’re only ever heating your house – not accidentally warming up the garden. There’s also a huge amount of variation in tech and pricing, which can make it difficult to figure out what you’re getting for your money and what a good deal looks like. In the past, we’ve been sceptical of brands’ claims that a smart heating system can deliver huge energy bill savings – several brands make claims of up to 30% savings. But with the rise in energy prices, that seems much more likely. If you use all the energy efficiency features, you will almost certainly lower your heating bills, and perhaps significantly. However, these savings won’t be instant as you’ll need to factor in the cost of the system and installation. To find out if smart heating is likely to save you money, we’ve got a dedicated article you might want to check out. We’ve tested most of the smart systems in the UK market and we’ve done our best to break down how each works, what features they have, how they’re installed and what might make them worth your money. If you’ve got an Ideal Boilers brand boiler from mid-2019 on, have a look at our article on the Halo Combi, which is specifically designed to be an Ideal-compatible smart heating system. Otherwise, read on for the best smart thermostats we’ve tested. And, if you’d like some buying advice, scroll past the chart for more information.
Best smart heating system reviews
Guide to buying smart home heating
The best smart heating system for you depends on the type of home you have, how you use it and how much money you can outlay to make longer-term savings.
Well designed Easy to use Geolocation tech Boost function
Not a learning device Most features accessible only via app
It has all the same features as the pricier Hive Thermostat – plus, it can control up to six heating zones, compared to the previous iteration’s three. But the big change is that most of the controls have been shifted away from the minimalist, touchscreen thermostat to the app. You’ll use the app to set up scheduling for your hot water and heating, switch on frost protection and holiday mode, turn on geolocation (so you’ll get an alert if you leave home without switching off your heating) and boost your heating and hot water. There’s the option to add to your set-up with Hive thermostatic radiator valves for granular room-by-room heating control, and the Thermostat Mini is compatible with with Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple HomeKit, Siri Shortcuts and IFTTT.
Easy to use interface Beautiful design Part of Hive ecosystem
Professional installation recommended
This second iteration of Hive is a giant leap forward from the solid (but somewhat dull) first-generation product. The interfaces of both the app and thermostat are intuitive and quick to use. There are clearly energy savings which Hive can help you make and you may be able to recoup your expenditure if you’re conservative with your temperatures and schedule. It’s easy to add the Hive Active Light, as well as smart plugs and switches.
Comprehensive Easy to use Convenient
Expensive
It’s very easy to use, even for technophobes and although it can take a while to set a schedule in the first place, making tweaks is quick and simple. If money is no object, we can highly recommend Evohome.
Easy installation Reasonably priced Multi-room
Weak signal from control box may require a booster
What it does do well is allow you to control the temperature separately in different rooms, via smart radiator valves, which are also easy to fit. The app is great, too, and several features have been added since launch, showing that it’s still being developed.
Well designed Can control your hot water
Works best in smaller homes
The Nest Protect smoke and carbon monoxide alarm also works with the thermostat, as does the Nest Cam camera. The 3rd generation can also control your hot water, making it even better, and the latest app update means your phone can tell it when you’ve gone out, so you don’t waste money heating an empty home.
Complete automation Prevents wasted heat
Installation recommended Subscription required
Being able to control the temperature (wherever you are) via an app on your phone is an ideal way to control your heating and energy costs. New inside and outside Air Comfort reports and Open Window Detection features, plus the ability to control multiple zones via smart radiator valves, improve on the central idea. Some of Tado’s best features are now locked behind a paid subscription, so you may want to bear that in mind before investing.
Easy to install Good value for US buyers
Limited features compared to Nest 3rd Gen
It’s a different story in the US though – a bigger price gap makes the E an easy recommendation if you’re in the States, it offers all of the most important features of the third-generation Nest, together with design improvements, for a significantly lower price.
Sophisticated temperature setting and scheduling
Limited functionality Most changes need to be made via the app
Netatmo lets you set a different schedule for every day of the week or create different schedules and switch between them, so you could have weekday and weekend heating schedules to fit your routine. Bear in mind that the display lets you adjust temperature and nothing else, so you’ll need a compatible phone or tablet to get the most from the system.
Good for larger homes and businesses Gives complete heating control
More expensive than rivals
But it is a great product, and if you are looking to install a zoned smart heating system, we are happy to recommend Genius – not least because of its potential as a true smart home network for your house.
Controls up to 30 rooms and 50 radiators Good app with useful features No data stored in the cloud Works with underfloor heating
Expensive to control every room No display on TRVs Requires professional installation
It uses smart radiator valves and temperature sensors working in combination to measure and control the heat in each room. And it has a great suite of smart features such as heat boost, geofencing and open window detection.
There are downsides, however. It’ll be an expensive initial investment to kit out all of your rooms and most people will also need to pay for professional installation.
There’s a way of making every house more efficient and more comfortable. But the best method for each house will differ.
The key question is the level to which you need – or want – to make your heating smart.
Most of these systems simply put a smart thermostat into the most-used room in the house or the hallway, and moderate the temperature of the whole house to match that room. For smaller houses, in which most rooms are in regular use, this is probably a cost-effective way of attaining the results you want. You can always turn off the radiators you don’t need to avoid heating rooms unnecessarily.
These thermostats also make it easier to set schedules and many have additional ‘smart’ features to make your heating more efficient and save you money. For example, some can detect when no one’s home and automatically turn off the heating, or do the same if a window is left ajar.
Honeywell Evohome, Tado, and Genius offer something better. One of the ways they do this is by replacing the valves on your radiators with ‘smart’ valves, although depending on which package you get, you may have to buy these separately.
They allow you to divide up your home into various zones and then offer smart heating in each zone, so your guest bedroom is heated only when required, the master bedroom is warm in the morning and at bedtime, and the kitchen is cosy at breakfast and tea time.
In the UK at least, all modern houses with living space covering ground greater than 150m2 have to be built with at least two zones of heating, according to 2013 Building Regulations Part L.
Tado can be smart-radiator based or a combination of room thermostat and zonal control via its smart radiator thermostats. These smart TRVs can often be used independently of the thermostat so you don’t necessarily need to buy the same brand and you can still use them with Nest, which doesn’t currently offer the valves. The only issue is that you’ll need two separate apps to control your heating.
Smart TRVs are also a great option for people in rented accommodation, as they don’t require permanent installation.
Honeywell, Genius and certain others can control more sophisticated heating systems (including underfloor heating and hot water tanks) but with this additional control comes a higher price tag.
So again: a well-used, modern, small house (or flat) is unlikely to need this level of sophistication, and a well-used large home may have sufficient zones plumbed in to make Nest or Hive a good solution. Just remember that you’ll need one thermostat per zone, so while it’s cheaper than fitting each radiator with a £50/$50 smart TRV, it’s still relatively expensive.
If you have a boiler and central heating, you will likely be able to fit any of the systems here.
The next questions to ask are about which additional features are important. There’s no point opting for a system that centres on location services, such as Tado, if there’s usually someone at home.
Remember that you might also want to supplement your central heating system with a separate portable system, which can give you some more manual control over where you heat. We’ve also reviewed portable heaters, so take a look for our recommendations.
Emma is Home Tech Editor at Tech Advisor. She covers everything from kitchen appliances to smart home devices, from floor care to personal care to air care technology. She’s particularly interested in environmentally conscious brands and products that save people time and money.
